Thanks to falsified dental records supplied by his former neighbor Nicholas "Oz" Oseransky (Perry), retired hitman Jimmy "The Tulip" Tudeski (Willis) now spends his days compulsively cleaning his house and perfecting his culinary skills with his wife Jill (Peet), a purported assassin who has yet to pull off a clean hit. Suddenly, an uninvited and unwelcome connection to their past unexpectedly shows up on Jimmy and Jill’s doorstep: it’s Oz, and he’s begging them to help him rescue his wife from a Hungarian mob. Together, they’ll have to go the whole nine yards "and then some" to manage the mounting Mafioso mayhem.